It seems common place now to just s**t on The Force Awakens as if it were akin to a Transformers film. I for one like to stand my ground on most films (depending how they age with multiple viewings) and I firmly stand behind my Force Awakens -- and Rogue One, which has aged very well -- review and initial response.
The point of all of this is to say that I think it's important to stick with your guns and opinions rather than letting the internet dictate them so much. Which is why that, despite how much I loved The Last Jedi, the eighth chapter in the Star Wars sage, I don't think it's quite as revolutionary as many are suggesting.
![]() |
"Wait...what did I have for breakfast this morning?" |
![]() |
"Let's go fight giant monsters with giant robots!" Ummm...wrong movie? |
The other, and really final, issue I had with The Last Jedi is that among it's several subplots, one key one doesn't really pay off at all. We have the Luke and Rey interactions and mystery that remains interesting, but when the film starts to follow Finn and new character Rose, I felt like I was watching a completely different, and lower quality, film. Their sidebar mission is fun in an entertaining sense, but it adds on to a hefty runtime of a film where audiences are pining for answers. Exercises in patience aside, it was a tad disappointing that not much ended up stemming from their mission and aside from building their friendship the movie could have probably eliminated it completely.
Don't let my review discourage you though because The Last Jedi is still an incredible Star Wars film. It's opening sequence is one of the most exciting in recent memory and basically right at the halfway point the film kicks it into high gear. Kudos immediately goes to the visual team and creative thinking behind The Last Jedi as most of the film's biggest scenes are visually arresting. I imagine director Rian Johnson deserves credit too for some of the most imaginative stuff we've seen in a while from the Star Wars universe. He's having fun playing with the toys at his disposal, but also making new ones along the way. A battle on a salt-crusted planet with red clay underneath is so pretty and alarming that I couldn't tear my eyes away, even if I'd tried. A few other setpieces are like this too, but I won't divulge into those much as some of the film's best looking scenes are also spoilers (sorry not sorry!).
![]() |
Such an awesome opening sequence |
The Last Jedi also comes packed with some awesome action. I already mentioned the early spacebattle but there's also a creative lightsaber sequence, one particular moment of unique weaponry I wont ruin, and a battle of sorts at the end. It's all filmed thoughtfully with strong editing and cinematography. There's a keen eye for the action here and a lot of it feels Lord of the Rings-esque in the best of ways. Most of the special effects throughout are incredible and in the scenes where you can tell where they spent the money, it shows with some of the best visuals of the year. As is the case for Star Wars films it's also accompanied by a highly-unique and utterly brilliant original score that continues that tradition, despite the quality of any given film. On an accompanying note, there's a lot of wonderful humor throughout The Last Jedi too, some of it subtle (i.e. Kylo's emo tendencies), some of it downright hilarious. Much has been said about the Porgs and yes, they likely only exist for toys, but I'm all about that #Porglyfe. They're adorable and have some of the biggest laughs in the film. I'm not sure any moment is gut-bustingly funnier than BB-8's "thumbs up" in Force Awakens but a lot of it is close and the humor -- often thanks to that little rolling dude himself -- is consistent throughout.
![]() |
Ominous Ocean: the newest rap album from Daisy Ridley |
Can't wait until we're all sh****ng on The Last Jedi in a few months once that becomes popular! /sarcasm
CONS
- Aside from reviews that made me think it would blow my mind, I do wish the creative team would have gone in one particular direction. To me, it made sense in the moment of the film and it would have left the entire gameplan up in the air. I think they played it too safe
- Finn and Rose's subplot is fun, but ultimately unnecessary and packs on a lot of extra runtime. This affects the film's pacing in the middle
- Few moments of shoddy special effects
- Captain Phasma once again sidelined
- A wonderful cast is back reprising some equally wonderful roles. It's great to have the talented Mark Hamill back, Ridley and Driver expand on what makes their characters so great, Isaac gets to nearly be the star of the show, and everyone else (newcomers and returning) are clearly into it
- Visually stunning. The ideation of some of these sets, creatures, and scenes must have been fun because the end result is some truly magnificent moments
- Probably one of the most creative Star Wars films out of the whole series. And that's saying a lot
- While I had my wishes with the story, it's still well thought out, answers some questions, has some genuine moments of shock, and wraps everything up nicely within the film
- A handful of year-best, standout scenes
- Fantastic special effects where it counts and the big action scenes are all the better (and wilder) for it
- Once again, that original score is undeniably iconic
- Funny in a multitude of ways and Porgs rock and if you hate them you're heartless
- A stunning middle chapter of this new saga that is just an absolute blast
Rath's Review Score | 8.5/10
I largely agree with you. Great start, brilliant ending, but a baggy middle and Finn and Rose's mission is a total bust. The Rey training bits were just Empire again. Nice looking film though and I love the Porgs!
ReplyDeleteAgreed! I thought there was just enough Porgs too. Used for calculated comedic relief but not at every turn.
DeleteMany of the reviews now seem to be noticeably more lukewarm than the initial ones. Somewhere in the middle is about right. Apparently, Snoak's look was based on Hugh Heffner!!!
DeleteI'm actually extremely curious as to what film the early critics saw. I dont disagree that the QUALITY of the film is there, but there were many that said "It flips the entire series on its head!" or "You'll walk out shaken to your core" -- I walked out feeling like I saw the most[ly] logical path.
Delete